Mary Coyle Ice Cream is the best ice cream around. Check out our menu below, so you know what you want when you walk through the door.
OL’ FAVORITES – “ALL THE TIMERS”
16% Butterfat Ice Cream • Made on the Premises
Ice Cream Flavors
Cookies ‘n Cream
Mint Chocolate Chip
Peanut Butter Chocolate
Salted Caramel Cashew
Seasonal Ice Cream Flavors
Peach (July 4th – Labor Day)
Pumpkin Pie (Oct. 15 – Nov. 30)
Egg Nog (Dec.)
Cookie in a Cup – one cookie & one dip
Cookie Sandwich – two cookies & one dip
Ice Cream Cones or Cups
Handmade Waffle Cones or Bowls
Ice Cream Flights
Your choice of 5, 4, or 3 two-ounce servings of any of our delicious flavors.
Handpacked Ice Cream to Go
Handpacked Pint or Quart
Your choice of one topping: Hot Fudge, Hot Caramel, Strawberry, Chocolate, Pineapple, Marshmallow, Cherry or Caramel. Upon request, topped with whip cream, a cherry & a side of granulated peanuts.
Shakes, Floats and Malts
Thick Ol’ Fashion Milkshake or Ol’ Fashion Ice Cream Soda
Vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, cherry, banana, raspberry, pineapple, coffee, caramel & marshmallow
Float – soda pop with dips of ice cream!
Root beer or Coke, “the ol’ fashion Black Cow”
Frosted – a float all mixed up!
Root beer or Coke, “the ol’ fashion Boston Cooler”
Freezes – a light and refreshing drink!
Soda water with our homemade sherbet all mixed up
Upon request, all Showboats topped with whip cream & a cherry.
The turtle “and the hare”
Butter pecan ice cream, hot fudge, caramel & crushed pecans
HOT TIN ROOF “IT LEAKS HOT FUDGE”
Vanilla ice cream, hot fudge topping & whole Spanish peanuts
HOT COPPER ROOF “IT LEAKS CARAMEL”
Vanilla ice cream, hot caramel topping & whole Spanish peanuts
CARAMEL CASHEW “GOD BLESS YOU”
Vanilla & salted caramel cashew ice cream, caramel topping, garnished with cashew pieces
THE COOKIE MAN “A MONSTER”
Cookies & cream ice cream, chocolate & marshmallow topping & crushed cookies
CAFE OLÉ “GOOD TO THE LAST DROP”
Ol’ Colonial coffee ice cream, hot fudge topping & almonds
CHERRY SNOW “BRING YOUR SHOVEL”
Burgundy cherry ice cream, marshmallow, cherry topping & garnished with coconut
TWIN CHIPS “RIGHT OFF THE OLD BLOCK”
Mint chocolate chip and chocolate chip ice cream, chocolate & marshmallow topping & almonds
PECAN PETE “IT’S A PISTOL”
Butter pecan ice cream, caramel topping & crushed pecans
MARY MINT “IT’S COOL MAN”
Peppermint chip ice cream & hot fudge topping
Specialties of the House
The Hill Choose from 4-6 of our favorite flavors
A huge “Hill” of ice cream. Four full pounds, plus whip cream & cherries. Two toppings & granulated peanuts included.
MOUNTAIN Choose from 7-9 of our favorite flavors
A veritable ice cream mountain. Seven full pounds, plus whip cream & cherries. Four toppings & granulated peanuts included.
GRAND CANYON Choose from 11-13 of our favorite flavors
Dig your way through this natural wonder. Eleven full pounds, plus whip cream & cherries. Six toppings & granulated peanuts included.
Choose from these toppings: Hot Fudge, Hot Caramel,
Strawberry, Chocolate, Pineapple, Marshmallow, Cherry or Caramel.
Vanilla, chocolate & strawberry ice cream, pineapple, fudge & strawberry toppings, fresh bananas. Upon request, topped with whip cream, cherries & a side of granulated peanuts.
Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Barq’s Root Beer, Hi-C Fruit Punch
Upon request, all Banana Bowls topped with whip cream & a cherry.
THE HOT FUDGE BOWL
Vanilla ice cream, hot fudge, fresh bananas & a side of granulated peanuts
THE STRAWBERRY BOWL
Vanilla ice cream, gobs of strawberries, fresh bananas & a side of granulated peanuts
THE ORIGINAL BOWL
Vanilla, chocolate & strawberry ice cream, cherry, pineapple & marshmallow toppings, fresh bananas & a side of granulated peanuts
THE HULA BOWL
Vanilla, burgundy cherry & maple walnut ice cream, pineapple topping, walnuts, fresh bananas, garnished with coconut & a side of granulated peanuts
THE HOT CARAMEL BOWL
Vanilla ice cream, hot caramel, fresh bananas & a side of granulated peanuts
THE CO-CO FUDGE “SOME DON’T” BOWL
Vanilla ice cream, hot fudge topping, fresh bananas, garnished with coconut & a side of granulated peanuts
THE DELIGHT-FUL “ANA BANA-RAMA” BOWL
Banana ice cream, fresh bananas, marshmallow topping & a side of granulated peanuts
Mary Coyle Ol' Fashion Ice Cream is a part of the fabric of modern Phoenix. The ice cream and the memories created when visiting Mary Coyle have been a staple for the families in the local community since 1951, when Mary moved to Phoenix from Ohio. The ice cream is nothing short of fantastic.