Mary Coyle Ol' Fashion Ice Cream

Mary Coyle Ol’ Fashion Ice Cream and Frozen Yogurt Menu

Mary Coyle Ice Cream is the best ice cream around. Check out our menu below, so you know what you want when you walk through the door.

OL’ FAVORITES – “ALL THE TIMERS”

16% Butterfat Ice Cream • Made on the Premises

  • Ice Cream Flavors

  • Vanilla

  • Chocolate

  • Strawberry

  • Banana

  • Black Licorice

  • Black Raspberry

  • Burgundy Cherry

  • Butter Pecan

  • Chocolate Chip

  • Coffee

  • Cookie Dough

  • Cookies ‘n Cream

  • Cotton Candy

  • Maple Walnut

  • Mint Chocolate Chip

  • Peanut Butter Chocolate

  • Peppermint Chip

  • Pistachio

  • Rocky Road

  • Salted Caramel Cashew

  • Spumoni

  • Seasonal Ice Cream Flavors

  • Peach (July 4th – Labor Day)

  • Pumpkin Pie (Oct. 15 – Nov. 30)

  • Egg Nog (Dec.)

  • Sherbet

  • Rainbow

  • Lime

  • Orange

  • Pineapple

  • Sorbet (Non-Dairy)

  • Raspberry

  • Sugar-Free

  • Vanilla

  • Non-Fat Yogurt

  • Vanilla

Cookie Delights

  • Cookie in a Cup – one cookie & one dip

  • Cookie Sandwich – two cookies & one dip

cookie in a cupmary coyle ice cream cookie sandwich

Traditional Treats

  • Ice Cream Cones or Cups

  • Handmade Waffle Cones or Bowls

mary coyle ice cream cake cone with strawberry ice cream and cotton candy ice creamwaffle-cone-web

Ice Cream Flights

Your choice of 5, 4, or 3 two-ounce servings of any of our delicious flavors.

Handpacked Ice Cream to Go

  • Handpacked Pint or Quart

Sundaes

Your choice of one topping: Hot Fudge, Hot Caramel, Strawberry, Chocolate, Pineapple, Marshmallow, Cherry or Caramel. Upon request, topped with whip cream, a cherry & a side of granulated peanuts.

single ice cream sundae at mary coyle ol' fashion ice cream

Shakes, Floats and Malts

Thick Ol’ Fashion Milkshake or Ol’ Fashion Ice Cream Soda
Vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, cherry, banana, raspberry, pineapple, coffee, caramel & marshmallow

old fashioned shake from mary coyle ice cream

Float – soda pop with dips of ice cream!
Root beer or Coke, “the ol’ fashion Black Cow”

float-menu

Frosted – a float all mixed up!
Root beer or Coke, “the ol’ fashion Boston Cooler”

frosted float

Freezes – a light and refreshing drink!
Soda water with our homemade sherbet all mixed up

freeze-menu

Showboats

Upon request, all Showboats topped with whip cream & a cherry.

The turtle “and the hare”
Butter pecan ice cream, hot fudge, caramel & crushed pecans

turtle and hare showboat sundae from mary coyle ol' fashion ice cream

HOT TIN ROOF “IT LEAKS HOT FUDGE”
Vanilla ice cream, hot fudge topping & whole Spanish peanuts

hot-tin-roof-sundae from Mary Coyle Ice Cream

HOT COPPER ROOF “IT LEAKS CARAMEL”
Vanilla ice cream, hot caramel topping & whole Spanish peanuts

hot copper roof showboat sundae from mary coyle ice cream

CARAMEL CASHEW “GOD BLESS YOU”
Vanilla & salted caramel cashew ice cream, caramel topping, garnished with cashew pieces

caramel cashew showboat at mary coyle ol fashion ice cream

THE COOKIE MAN “A MONSTER”
Cookies & cream ice cream, chocolate & marshmallow topping & crushed cookies

cookie-man-menu

CAFE OLÉ “GOOD TO THE LAST DROP”
Ol’ Colonial coffee ice cream, hot fudge topping & almonds

the Café Olé showboat Sundae from Mary Coyle Ice Cream in Phoenix

CHERRY SNOW “BRING YOUR SHOVEL”
Burgundy cherry ice cream, marshmallow, cherry topping & garnished with coconut

cherry snow showboat from mary coyle ice cream

TWIN CHIPS “RIGHT OFF THE OLD BLOCK”
Mint chocolate chip and chocolate chip ice cream, chocolate & marshmallow topping & almonds

Twin chips ice cream sundae from Mary Coyle Ice Cream in Phoenix

PECAN PETE “IT’S A PISTOL”
Butter pecan ice cream, caramel topping & crushed pecans

pecan-pete-menu

MARY MINT “IT’S COOL MAN”
Peppermint chip ice cream & hot fudge topping

mary mint showboat sundae from mary coyle ol' fashion ice cream

Specialties of the House

The Hill Choose from 4-6 of our favorite flavors

A huge “Hill” of ice cream. Four full pounds, plus whip cream & cherries. Two toppings & granulated peanuts included.

MOUNTAIN Choose from 7-9 of our favorite flavors

A veritable ice cream mountain. Seven full pounds, plus whip cream & cherries. Four toppings & granulated peanuts included.

GRAND CANYON Choose from 11-13 of our favorite flavors

Dig your way through this natural wonder. Eleven full pounds, plus whip cream & cherries. Six toppings & granulated peanuts included.

the grand canyon at mary coyle ice cream

Choose from these toppings: Hot Fudge, Hot Caramel,
Strawberry, Chocolate, Pineapple, Marshmallow, Cherry or Caramel.

Banana Splits

Vanilla, chocolate & strawberry ice cream, pineapple, fudge & strawberry toppings, fresh bananas. Upon request, topped with whip cream, cherries & a side of granulated peanuts.

an Ol' Fashion banana split from Mary Coyle Ice Cream

Beverages

Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Barq’s Root Beer, Hi-C Fruit Punch

Banana Bowls

Upon request, all Banana Bowls topped with whip cream & a cherry.

THE HOT FUDGE BOWL
Vanilla ice cream, hot fudge, fresh bananas & a side of granulated peanuts

a Hot Fudge Banana Bowl sundae from Mary Coyle Ol' Fashion Ice Cream

THE STRAWBERRY BOWL
Vanilla ice cream, gobs of strawberries, fresh bananas & a side of granulated peanuts

vanilla ice cream bowl with strawberry topping

THE ORIGINAL BOWL
Vanilla, chocolate & strawberry ice cream, cherry, pineapple & marshmallow toppings, fresh bananas & a side of granulated peanuts

An Original Banana Bowl from Mary Coyle Ice Cream

THE HULA BOWL
Vanilla, burgundy cherry & maple walnut ice cream, pineapple topping, walnuts, fresh bananas, garnished with coconut & a side of granulated peanuts

the hula bowl sundae from mary coyle ol fashion ice cream

THE HOT CARAMEL BOWL
Vanilla ice cream, hot caramel, fresh bananas & a side of granulated peanuts

hot caramel banana bow with mary coyle ol fashion ice cream

THE CO-CO FUDGE “SOME DON’T” BOWL
Vanilla ice cream, hot fudge topping, fresh bananas, garnished with coconut & a side of granulated peanuts

Co-Co Fudge Some Don't banana bowl sundae from Mary Coyle Ol' Fashion Ice Cream

THE DELIGHT-FUL “ANA BANA-RAMA” BOWL
Banana ice cream, fresh bananas, marshmallow topping & a side of granulated peanuts

ana banana rama ice cream bowl

Our Story

Mary Coyle Ol' Fashion Ice Cream is a part of the fabric of modern Phoenix. The ice cream and the memories created when visiting Mary Coyle have been a staple for the families in the local community since 1951, when Mary moved to Phoenix from Ohio. The ice cream is nothing short of fantastic.